BLOGS
Joshua Marshall
Daily Kos
Eschaton
Rising Hegemon
AmericaBlog
Jason Zada
Jose Luis
Kevin Byrd
What Do I Know
Binky
Scenestars
brownglasses

Neil Gaiman
Powazek

FAVORITES
Ain't It Cool
Dark Horizons
Defamer
Coming Attractions
Variety
Hollywood Reporter
Hollywood Elsewhere
View Askew
IMDB
Rotten Tomatoes
Trailer Park
Drew's Script-O-Rama
Box Office Mojo
---------------------
DVD File
The Digital Bits
Criterion Collection
---------------------
CNN
MSNBC
Drudge Report
Salon
The Gate
ESPNet
S.F. Giants
---------------------
Amazing Fantasy #15
Superhero Hype
ComiCon.com News
Newsarama
Comics Continuum
Cartoon Brew
Animation World News
Sarge!
Red Meat
---------------------
Neil Finn
Nil Fun
Billy Bragg
Jon Brion
Wilco
Prefab Sprout
---------------------
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
DVD Empire
Ebay.com
Bowen Designs
---------------------
The Nation
Truthout
MoveOn.org
Misleader
Iraq on the Record
Kerry for President
Michael Moore
Air America Radio
Greg Palast
---------------------
The Onion
Raving Toy Maniac
Mark Ryden
The Smoking Gun
---------------------
Slower
toycamera.com
---------------------
ComicBookFonts.com
Blambot!
House Industries
---------------------
Apple Computer
MacCentral
Versiontracker
Think Secret
SpyMac
---------------------
Ipod Lounge
Ipoding

Everything iPod
---------------------
Palm
News.Com
Shareware.com
Adobe
Hotmail


Posted 5:41pm, Tuesday, September 14, 2004

Catching up with some notes on Memogate...

Found this story on ABC News:

"Bush spokesman Scott McClellan said Friday the White House, which distributed the memos after obtaining them from CBS News, was not trying to verify their authenticity.

"We don't know if the documents are fabricated or authentic," McClellan told reporters traveling with the president to West Virginia."

The White House doesn't know?

This is practically an admission. I mean, if in fact these documents were forgeries, wouldn't Georgie be the one to know? Wouldn't a firm denial quickly follow? Why wait for the press to hash out the truth if you know these documents to be phony?

If the above non-denial wasn't enough, you've got White House Communications director Dan Bartlett practically admitting guilt:

"But at the time, I had every reason to believe that a major news organization had authentic documents."

USA Today has some more Texas Air National Guard documents which line-up with CBS's conclusions.

Yes, they are in the same "questionable" font, which becomes way less questionable when you visit PC World's examination of Microsoft word versus the IBM Selectric.... THEY LOOK IDENTICAL.

"Of course, none of this demonstrates that the documents dated from the early 1970s are in fact genuine. It only demonstrates that the fact that the disputed documents can be reproduced in Microsoft Word is not convincing evidence that they are inauthentic."

And Time Magazine chimes in with their expert:

Bill Glennon, a technology consultant in New York City who worked for IBM repairing typewriters from 1973 to 1985, says those experts "are full of crap. They just don't know."

Glennon says there were IBM machines capable of producing the spacing, and a customized key -- the likes of which he says were not unusual -- could have created the superscript th.

So again, we're left to determine the authenticity of the documents in a he said/she said situation. I think the only way to determine this is by having access to the original documents and have the paper and inks dated.

In case you're looking for a humorous way to wrap up the whole Memogate thing, we give you Bob Novak.

On the CNN panel show, "Capital Gang," Novak expressed grave doubts about the CBS documents, then said: "I'd like CBS, at this point, to say where they got these documents
from. They didn't get them from a CIA agent. I don't believe there was any laws involved. I don't think we'll have a special prosecutor, if they tell. I think they should say where they got these documents because I thought it was a very poor job of reporting by CBS...."

Fellow panelist, Al Hunt, from the Wall Street Journal, then replied: "Robert Novak, you're saying CBS should reveal its source?"

The transcript continues:

NOVAK: Yes.

HUNT: You do? You think reporters ought to reveal sources?

NOVAK: No, no. Wait a minute.

HUNT: I'm just asking.

NOVAK: I'm just saying in that case.

HUNT: Oh.

NOVAK: I think -- I think it's very important. If this is a phony document, the American -- the people should know about it.

HUNT: So in some cases, reporters ought to reveal sources.

NOVAK: Yes.

HUNT: But not in all cases.

NOVAK: That's right.

HUNT: OK. Mark Shields, what's the relevance of all this?

SHIELDS: A point well taken, Al.

Novak, of course, was one of the two reporters subpoened by the F.B.I. in their investigation of the leaked identity of C.I.A. agent Valerie Plame by a White House source. Novak refused to reveal the identity of his source.

For the above exchange, he was awarded Douchebag of the Week by Jon Stewart on The Daily Show.


"It is critical that the president of the United States speak clearly and consistently at this time of great threat in our world, and not change positions because of expediency or pressure." - George W. Bush, 9/14/04

"Too many good docs are getting out of the business. Too many OB/GYN's aren't able to practice their... their love with women all across the country." - George W. Bush, 9/6/04

"So community colleges are accessible, they're available, they're affordable, and their curriculums don't get stuck. In other words, if there's a need for a certain kind of worker, I presume your curriculums evolved over time." - George W. Bush, 8/10/04

"Tribal sovereignty means that, it's sovereign. You're a—you've been given sovereignty, and you're viewed as a sovereign entity. And, therefore, the relationship between the federal government and tribes is one between sovereign entities."- George W. Bush, 8/6/04 (click for video; Quicktime required)

"Secondly, the tactics of our—as you know, we don't have relationships with Iran. I mean, that's—ever since the late '70s, we have no contacts with them, and we've totally sanctioned them. In other words, there's no sanctions—you can't—we're out of sanctions." - George W. Bush, 8/9/04

"Our enemies are innovative and resourceful, and so are we. They never stop thinking about new ways to harm our country and our people, and neither do we." - George W. Bush, 8/5/04

 

©2004 Ron Lim unless noted


2004
9.5.04
8.13.04
8.6.04
8.5.04
7.26.04
7.18.04
7.12.04
7.4.04
6.29.04
5.13.04
5.9.04
5.4.04
4.24.04
4.18.04
4.11.04
3.29.04
3.22.04
3.17.04
3.14.04
3.1.04
2.16.04
1.23.04
1.1.04

2003
12.24.03
12.14.03

12.12.03

11.16.03
10.15.03
10.12.03
10.7.03
10.5.03
9.28.03
9.18.03
9.7.03
9.2.03
8.21.03
8.20.03
8.10.03
7.6.03
6.4.03
4.14.03
3.17.03
2/16/03
1/20/03

2002
12.24.02
12.10.02
11.16.02
10.30.02
10.13.02
10.4.02
9.18.02
9.14.02
9.11.02
9.4.02
8.27.02
8.25.02
8.13.02
8.8.02
8.7.02, 9pm
8.7.02, 8pm
8.6.02
7.25.02
7.22.02

OLDER
Pulp Fiction
9-11-01

ON MY IPOD
Supergrass-
Supegrass is 10
Badly Drawn Boy-
One Plue One is One
The Blue Nile-High

 

KEYWORDS: Ron Lim, Ron W. Lim, blog, art direction, advertising, photographs, illustration, Spider-man, Amazing Fantasy #15, comics